Grade my team please!

[HarryCaray]

I really really like it, I think Charles-Forte-Fitzgerald was as good of a start as I could have possibly hoped for in a 12 man league. So, 12 man PPR league, start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 RB/WR/TE flex, 1 TE, 1K, 1D...

QB - Stafford
RB - Jamaal Charles
RB - Forte
WR - Larry Fitz
WR - Brandon Marshall
TE - Jermichael Finley
Flex - Santana Moss
K - Vinatieri
D - Saints

Bench-
QB - Sam Bradford
RB - Mark Ingram, Ricky Williams
WR - Kenny Britt, Robert Meachem
TE - Rob Gronkowski


Let's hear it...

 

[TheCommish]

Looks like a 4th place team. I like Charles and Forte, not the best but solid. WR's are shaky in possible production. Here me out...both Fitz and MArshall are both beasts of WR's but their QB play to me is questionable. Henne may turn out to develop some chemistry with Marshall and I hope that they can work that out. As of now they seem to be warm or very cold. Kolb has the arm and Fitz will bail him out some bad throws this year. My concern is can Kolb stay upright all year...and if he can will he (same as Henne) develop chemistry with Fitz. Finley is a badass TE, I like him a lot. Stafford...well this could be his break out year coming off surgery and with an improved team. If he comes along and performs beyond expectations I would consider your team higher than a 4th place team. Don't know about Moss in the flex spot again hot or cold type of fantasy scorer. Love Bradford ( he may be your #1 QB). Depending on the scoring of your League would determine who I would put in the flex spot. Again these are just my opinions. I wish you the Best of luck in your league.

 

[lax_gunman]

I think you did pretty well HC. Do you really think Gronk is worth a roster spot though as a backup TE. Did you have the 4th pick?
I actual drafted Stafford and Bradford back to back in a mock draft and liked my team.

 

[billhill999]

B-

Like the Fitz draft

 

[mjh12795]

I think britt might have a better year than marshall

 

[HarryCaray]

I think you did pretty well HC. Do you really think Gronk is worth a roster spot though as a backup TE. Did you have the 4th pick?
I actual drafted Stafford and Bradford back to back in a mock draft and liked my team.

Obviously yes I do think Gronk is worth a roster spot.

3rd pick

 

[HarryCaray]

Looks like a 4th place team. I like Charles and Forte, not the best but solid. WR's are shaky in possible production. Here me out...both Fitz and MArshall are both beasts of WR's but their QB play to me is questionable. Henne may turn out to develop some chemistry with Marshall and I hope that they can work that out. As of now they seem to be warm or very cold. Kolb has the arm and Fitz will bail him out some bad throws this year. My concern is can Kolb stay upright all year...and if he can will he (same as Henne) develop chemistry with Fitz. Finley is a badass TE, I like him a lot. Stafford...well this could be his break out year coming off surgery and with an improved team. If he comes along and performs beyond expectations I would consider your team higher than a 4th place team. Don't know about Moss in the flex spot again hot or cold type of fantasy scorer. Love Bradford ( he may be your #1 QB). Depending on the scoring of your League would determine who I would put in the flex spot. Again these are just my opinions. I wish you the Best of luck in your league.

Agree with most of your points. Thanks for the feedback

 

[HarryCaray]

I think you did pretty well HC. Do you really think Gronk is worth a roster spot though as a backup TE. Did you have the 4th pick?
I actual drafted Stafford and Bradford back to back in a mock draft and liked my team.

Oh, and thanks for the feedback.

I'm liking Stafford and Bradford...let's say I hated them at first but I'm coming around on the tandem...

 

[HarryCaray]

B-

Like the Fitz draft

Thanks, I was shocked he was still there in the middle of round 3...

 

[HarryCaray]

Looks like a 4th place team. I like Charles and Forte, not the best but solid. WR's are shaky in possible production. Here me out...both Fitz and MArshall are both beasts of WR's but their QB play to me is questionable. Henne may turn out to develop some chemistry with Marshall and I hope that they can work that out. As of now they seem to be warm or very cold. Kolb has the arm and Fitz will bail him out some bad throws this year. My concern is can Kolb stay upright all year...and if he can will he (same as Henne) develop chemistry with Fitz. Finley is a badass TE, I like him a lot. Stafford...well this could be his break out year coming off surgery and with an improved team. If he comes along and performs beyond expectations I would consider your team higher than a 4th place team. Don't know about Moss in the flex spot again hot or cold type of fantasy scorer. Love Bradford ( he may be your #1 QB). Depending on the scoring of your League would determine who I would put in the flex spot. Again these are just my opinions. I wish you the Best of luck in your league.

Marshall will need a steady arm back there, he could turn out to be a total dud.

I think Fitz produces regardless of QB stability. A healthy Kolb would obviously help out his numbers, but he puts up solid numbers regardless IMO.

Can't decide right now on Moss or Ingram in the flex spot. I actually drafted Ingram before S Moss...

 

[HarryCaray]

I think britt might have a better year than marshall

Wouldn't surprise me at all...

 

[HarryCaray]

Don't know about Moss in the flex spot again hot or cold type of fantasy scorer

Yeah, I was hoping someone better would be available too with a late 8th round pick...

 

[HacheMan]

Sam Bradford could end up being your starter over Stafford.
Not because of injury, but because of numbers.

What round did you take TE Finley in and which TE went before him, if any?

 

[HarryCaray]

Sam Bradford could end up being your starter over Stafford.
Not because of injury, but because of numbers.

What round did you take TE Finley in and which TE went before him, if any?

Yeah agree, I took Stafford and then Bradford in rounds 7 and 8; I wasn't dead set on starting Stafford all year when healthy then and I'm not set on it now. I'll probably play matchups week by week with them (assuming they both stay healthy).

I took Finley in round 5. Gates and Dallas Clark were the only TE's off the board when I took him.

 

[HarryCaray]

Yeah, I was hoping someone better would be available too with a late 8th round pick...

Correction, Santana Moss was a 10th round pick

 

[TheCommish]

Correction, Santana Moss was a 10th round pick

Nice 10th rounder...Consistent QB play will determine his value. At a 10th rounder that may be great value.